The BBC is set to broadcast a programme which aims to see if kids can go gender free.
In this bold, engaging and provocative experiment, Doctor Javid Abdelmoneim aims to find out whether stripping away the pink and blue will change the way this class of seven-year-olds think.
Being gender neutral
Taking over one Year 3 class from Lanesend primary school in the Isle of Wight, Doctor Javid aims to remove all differences in the way boys and girls are treated to see if, after six weeks of gender neutral treatment, he can even out the gaps in their achievement across a range of important psychological measures from self-confidence to spatial awareness.
As a doctor, he knows there are basic biological differences between the sexes, but he believes our biology can’t fully explain why men and women’s life chances – from pay, to careers are still so unequal in the UK. Even a quick shopping trip reveals just how much childhood has changed since Dr. Javid was growing up, with a tsunami of pink and blue clothes and toys aimed at different genders. A visit to Professor Gina Rippon at Aston University, one of the UK’s leading experts in brain imaging and neuroscience, reveals there is no such thing as a male or female brain type and instead the brain is a plastic organ, shaped and moulded by experiences, in which childhood is key.
Shocked by the children’s own polarised opinions on how boys and girls should live their lives, Doctor Javid commissions Dr Stella Mavroveli from the Psychometric Lab at University College London to assess between boys and girls behaviour and psychological traits from confidence to self-esteem, empathy and social skills. Upset by the results, Dr Javid sets out a series of interventions both in class and at home, to tackle these differences. Will Doctor Javid’s gender neutral mission produce meaningful change when he later repeats his tests at the end of term?
There are two episodes in this series, episode 1 will broadcast on Wednesday 16th August and the second will air on the 23rd August. Times to be confirmed, both will be broadcast on BBC 2
No More Boys And Girls: Can Our Kids Go Gender Free? is produced by Outline Productions for BBC Two
Of course, this two-part series will be immediately used to attack trans children, despite its title and declared aim being to remove gender bias against self-belief and achievement amongst the children in the “experiment”.
Going to a crusading “there is no difference between male and female brains” feminist for the “expert” scientific opinion immediately attacks anyone who knows their brain gender is not “plastic”, and amenable to conversion therapy. People whose brain matches the sex assigned at birth have of course no real problem with that because no one ever tries to “convert” their gender.
Gina Rippon uses stupid, speculative, over-interpretations by authors of studies that show gender differences to supposedly dismiss there being any such thing as brain gender whatsoever, but that isn’t scientific either. Reproductive instincts are in the brain, and the core of gendered behaviour. Some responses that are not exclusively to do with reproduction flow from the same parts of the brain and influence aspects of life. Cortisol response in situations of stress, and fear, that affect the ability to learn during stress, for example. Whatever we are taught, or learn, that gives us skills, or confidence, or deprives us of them, in various ways (for example in maths, or navigation), those ancient and core differences are still there, and different – along a spectrum – by brain gender that is create before birth or in the first days after, not by sex of the body.
Showing children that their gender doesn’t need to dictate their success, confidence, skills, is admirable, but please beware thinking that justifies declaring that children don’t know what gender they are.